I'm never listening to music with someone i go out with ever again. When they leave the song goes with them, i can't afford to lose anymore of my jams.That statement, written by Brace Paine (from the band Gossip), has stuck with me ever since I first read it, and not just because of the grammatical flaws.
Back when I was still working in college radio, I won a Gossip promotion that was sponsored by Myspace and one of the promoters our station dealt with. Part of the prize pack was this odd little typewritten book of thoughts, stories, and blurbs like this, all of which were authored by Paine. This tiny bit of text resonated with me then and is still always lurking in the back of my mind when music and relationships become intertwined.
Why? Because it's 100% true.
There was a time when I couldn't listen to Neutral Milk Hotel for over a year. The sad but honest reason for that? It was a band my boyfriend had introduced me to while we were dating and, after we broke up, it hurt me to hear those same songs that I once loved. Every note, every lyric sung in Jeff Mangum's voice, brought memories flooding back. They reminded me that those good times, with that specific gentleman, were over and done for. Sure, we remained friendly but friendly wasn't what I associated those songs with; I associated them with being in love. Being in love with him.
Music, much like images and smells, can spark memories. We associate these types of stimuli with certain people, experiences, or times in our lives. It's something that, as much as we may try to fight it, is fairly involuntary. I can't hear Saves the Day without thinking of a "backseat mosh pit" on the way to the Webster or my former friend Meagan. I can't listen to their song "You Vandal" without thinking of the weeks I spent as an exchange student in Costa Rica. I can't even hear Bayside's name without thinking about 10 person trips to Denny's (and a waitress who didn't write anything down but only forgot one soda), Pez, Lizzie McGuire, dragging mattresses down a hall or the fact that *** was, apparently "a robot." It's the same feeling I get when I smell a particular cologne; it still makes me think of my high school crush. It's the same way I feel every time I walk into the coffee shop where my ex used to work. The same pang of sadness I get when I smell Tiger Balm and think about how much I miss my grandmother. These things all bring up memories, both good and bad.
For me, music is the ultimate stimulus. Whether it be one song, one hook, or just the name of a band. I've always been a music aficionado. I've listened to it. Written about it. Sang along to it. Attended a ridiculous number of shows, both small and intimate and large and crowded. My passion for music resulted in me working at a small club my freshman year of college, being actively involved in college radio for 6 years and, then, spending more than the last 4 years working at a music venue.
Every friendship, every relationship, has always left me wondering if I was going to lose another band. Have myself robbed of another Neutral Milk Hotel. Shared interests are what tie a lot of us together but it also makes things difficult when those bonds come undone. They remind us of that person, those memories, that time when everything was great. Hearing them after is just a reminder of what we once treasured but lost. There are certain tracks I avoid because I know there's a set of lyrics that will rip my heart out. There are entire albums I can only listen to in certain settings. There are concerts that delight me but also still manage to leave me with a pit in my stomach. I don't want to lose those jams. Not for a brief time and certainly not permanently. If only there was an off-switch that allowed you to keep music and memories entirely separate.
![]() |
| A Post Secret I could have easily written (but did not). |
The Hold Steady line I choose for the title of this blog post is yet another line I couldn't agree with more. Certain songs, they get so scratched into our souls.


